Achieving the perfect eyeliner look be it a sharp wing, sultry smudge, or classic tightline requires the right product. With so many options on the market, finding an eyeliner that offers precision and stays put all day can be a challenge.
Here, I’ve curated a list of the best eyeliners for precision and smudge-proof wear, drawing from personal experiences and expert insights. Let’s dive into the details to help you find your new go-to eyeliner.
Table of Contents
Best Overall Eyeliner
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
Who It’s For: Anyone seeking a reliable, all-day eyeliner with a sleek finish.
This eyeliner’s precision tip makes application seamless, whether you’re a beginner or a pro. The waterproof formula stays intact through tears, sweat, and long days. I’ve used this product on busy days when I needed my makeup to last from morning to evening, and it delivered every time.
Pros:
- Long-lasting formula
- Easy-to-use applicator
- Wide shade range
Cons:
- May dry out if not properly sealed
Best Crayon Eyeliner
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! 24-Hour Waterproof Eyeliner
Who It’s For: Those who love creamy, blendable formulas for versatile looks.
This eyeliner crayon glides effortlessly, making it ideal for both sharp lines and smudged, smoky eyes. The 24-hour wear claim holds true; I’ve worn it during long nights out without any smudging.
Pros:
- Creamy texture
- Smudge-resistant
- Long wear time
Cons:
- Requires frequent sharpening
Best Budget Pick
e.l.f. Cosmetics Intense H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen
Who It’s For: Budget-conscious beauty lovers who don’t want to compromise on quality.
This eyeliner offers incredible value for its price. Its precise tip and water-resistant formula make it a great choice for everyday wear. I’ve recommended it to friends new to makeup, and they’ve loved it.
Pros:
- Affordable
- Precise application
- Water-resistant
Cons:
- Limited color options
Best Gel Eyeliner
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner
Who It’s For: Fans of gel liners who prioritize smooth application and lasting power.
This cult favorite is beloved for a reason. Its smooth texture and impressive staying power make it a staple in many makeup kits. I use it for dramatic looks, and it never disappoints.
Pros:
- Intense pigmentation
- Long-lasting
- Versatile
Cons:
- Requires a brush for application
Best Pen Eyeliner
Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner
Who It’s For: Those who want a bold, precise line with minimal effort.
Rihanna’s beauty line doesn’t skimp on quality, and this eyeliner is proof. Its ultra-black formula and flexible tip make creating wings a breeze. I’ve relied on it for photo-ready looks.
Pros:
- Rich pigmentation
- Flexible, precise tip
- Smudge-proof
Cons:
- Can fade slightly on oily lids
Best Pencil Eyeliner
Lancôme Drama Liqui-Pencil
Who It’s For: Anyone looking for a pencil that combines the ease of application with intense color.
This pencil eyeliner stands out for its creamy texture and vibrant shades. I’ve used it to create colorful lower lash lines that last all day.
Pros:
- Wide shade range
- Creamy and easy to apply
- Long-lasting
Cons:
- Slightly pricier than other pencils
Best for Oily Lids
COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lash Enhancing Liquid Eyeliner
Who It’s For: Those with oily lids who struggle to keep their eyeliner in place.
This formula is specifically designed to combat smudging on oily lids. I tested it during summer, and it stayed flawless despite the heat.
Pros:
- Smudge-proof for oily lids
- Easy application
- Affordable
Cons:
- Limited color selection
Best for Sharp Wings
One/Size by Patrick Starrr Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen
Who It’s For: Perfectionists who love ultra-sharp wings.
This eyeliner pen’s precise tip allows for intricate designs and sharp wings. I used it for a wedding look, and it held up through tears and dancing.
Pros:
- Extremely precise
- Waterproof
- Long-lasting
Cons:
- Slight learning curve for beginners
Best for Color Lovers
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
Who It’s For: Makeup enthusiasts who love experimenting with bold colors.
This eyeliner offers an unparalleled shade range, from vibrant blues to metallic golds. I’ve created some of my most creative looks using these pencils.
Pros:
- Extensive shade range
- Blendable
- Long wear time
Cons:
- Can smudge slightly in humid conditions
Best for Beginners
Haus Labs Micro-Tip Eye-Lin-Ner
Who It’s For: Eyeliner novices who need an easy-to-use product.
This micro-tip eyeliner pen simplifies application for beginners. I’ve recommended it to friends starting their makeup journey, and they’ve found it incredibly user-friendly.
Pros:
- Easy to control
- Precise tip
- Smudge-proof
Cons:
- Limited shade options
What to Look for in an Eyeliner
Choosing the right eyeliner depends on your preferences and needs. Here are some factors to consider:
- Formula: Liquid, gel, pencil, or crayon—each has its strengths.
- Longevity: Look for waterproof or long-wear formulas for all-day wear.
- Applicator: A fine tip offers precision, while a crayon is great for smudging.
- Skin Type: If you have oily lids, opt for a smudge-proof formula.
- Color Options: Whether you love classic black or bold hues, pick a brand with a wide range of shades.
Why Trust Us
I’ve spent years testing and reviewing beauty products, collaborating with industry experts, and experimenting with countless eyeliner brands. My goal is to provide honest, practical advice to help you find the best products for your unique needs. Every product on this list has been personally tested or recommended by trusted sources.
Finding the perfect eyeliner can transform your makeup routine. Whether you’re after precision, longevity, or a pop of color, the options on this list have you covered. Which eyeliner will you try next? Let us know in the comments below!
